Evolve and AvantStay are both notable companies in the short-term rental management space. Evolve focuses on streamlined marketing and reservation support, allowing property owners to handle most on-the-ground operations or coordinate with local vendors.
AvantStay, by contrast, brands itself as a full-service manager that caters primarily to larger homes intended for group travel. Each option offers unique advantages and drawbacks depending on the level of service you seek and the type of property you own. Below, we compare their core offerings, costs, and terms to help you make an informed decision.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Overview
Evolve was founded in 2011, with headquarters in Denver, Colorado. It has grown quickly by focusing on marketing, pricing optimization, and booking management, which it provides at a competitive 10% fee. Evolve’s key selling point is a lighter-service model that relies on owners or local service providers for cleaning, maintenance, restocking, and guest check-ins. In exchange, property owners benefit from Evolve’s highly visible online listings, professional photography (included once the property is eligible), and centralized reservation system.
AvantStay, established in 2017 and based in Los Angeles, takes an entirely different approach. It positions itself as an all-inclusive manager, especially attractive to owners of larger properties and luxury vacation homes. AvantStay’s brand identity revolves around curated guest experiences for group travelers, boasting award-winning interior design, in-house housekeeping, and specialized technology to oversee each vacation rental. Although AvantStay has garnered significant funding, it is less transparent about its exact fees, instead customizing pricing based on the property and market.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Locations
Evolve operates across the United States, Canada, and Mexico. It targets popular vacation rental destinations and relies on its owners to organize on-the-ground services as needed. This approach allows Evolve to scale its marketing reach, with minimal investment in local infrastructure.
AvantStay covers around 13 US states plus Baja California Sur in Mexico, focusing primarily on upscale or group-friendly travel markets. Its portfolio spans Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Hawaii, Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, and select parts of Mexico. In each market, AvantStay works with local staff trained to handle cleaning, maintenance, and guest support. This in-house approach can enhance consistency and service quality, but the company’s footprint is more limited geographically than Evolve’s.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Costs & Fees
Evolve charges a flat 10% of monthly rental revenue for its core marketing and reservation services, making it one of the most budget-friendly models in the short-term rental space. Owners either handle or contract out tasks like cleaning, restocking, and property upkeep. While this arrangement can be cheaper for those who have existing vendor relationships, it does require more hands-on involvement from the owner.
AvantStay does not publicize a fixed fee structure. Property owners typically need to submit details about their home or portfolio and speak with an AvantStay representative to receive a personalized quote. In third-party reports and owner feedback, the company’s commission often ranges from 20% to 30% of monthly revenue. This range reflects the intensive level of service and the premium brand focus on group accommodations. Owners are advised to confirm whether any add-on costs will apply, especially for specific design requests, licenses, or additional insurance.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Services
Evolve excels in listing optimization, dynamic pricing, and booking management. Once an owner is onboarded, Evolve handles the photography for eligible properties, crafts a compelling listing, and markets the rental on major platforms like Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com. From there, Evolve’s reservation team communicates with guests up to the point of check-in. Beyond booking, hosts or their chosen vendors address things like linen changes, property cleaning, maintenance, and restocking, while Evolve remains a resource for marketing and pricing advice.
AvantStay differentiates itself with a turnkey solution. It assists owners in staging and furnishing properties, integrating smart technology for access and security, and securing commercial-grade insurance coverage. The company’s in-house teams clean, maintain, and restock each property, ensuring a consistent guest experience. AvantStay also offers centralized guest communication and support through phone, email, and SMS. Another focus is weekly revenue management reviews that combine automated tools with human oversight. This level of involvement frees hosts from nearly all operational burdens, though it typically commands higher fees.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Terms
Evolve operates on a month-to-month basis without long-term contracts, billing itself as a “risk-free” solution. Owners, however, are responsible for fulfilling any confirmed guest reservations if they decide to leave. Listings remain associated with Evolve’s internal host accounts on Airbnb or Vrbo, so reviews under Evolve’s profile do not transfer if an owner opts out of the service.
AvantStay requests that owners sign a contract, often for at least one year, and can accommodate multi-year agreements. The company’s online information is less explicit about notice periods, so it is important to clarify cancellation terms before committing. Additionally, AvantStay’s requirement for properties with a minimum of four bedrooms and group-friendly layouts restricts who qualifies. When hosts do exit, they typically lose access to the listing accounts and reviews, since AvantStay manages everything under its own corporate profiles.
Evolve vs AvantStay: Host Reviews
Evolve generally receives positive feedback regarding its cost-effectiveness and professional listing strategies, with hosts praising increased booking volume and a slick online dashboard. Complaints sometimes stem from owners who hoped for more help with maintenance, cleaning, or guest issues in person. For those tasks, Evolve remains a partial-service solution, leaving owners to coordinate on-the-ground logistics themselves.
AvantStay garners favorable reviews for offering a high-end guest experience and for effectively managing larger vacation rentals. Hosts often highlight the ease of handing over day-to-day tasks, from cleaning to restocking, to the company’s in-house teams. On the negative side, some owners voice concerns about pricing clarity and the relatively narrow focus on properties that meet AvantStay’s style and size criteria. When disputes do occur, they sometimes relate to misaligned expectations over costs or service deliverables.
Best Alternatives to Evolve and AvantStay
If neither a partially managed nor a fully managed approach fits your needs, there are other options worth exploring. Vacasa, for instance, is one of the largest providers of short-term rental management in North America, though it often charges higher fees. RedAwning is known for its robust marketing and distribution platform, offering an alternative to Evolve’s approach by providing 24/7 guest support and optional add-ons for property services in select areas. Awning is a nationwide company that merges a tech-driven pricing system with local expertise, charging 15% for fully managed services. Casago operates on an 18% fee structure and offers extensive coverage with in-house local teams, maintaining a strong presence in the U.S. and Mexico.
These companies vary in their levels of involvement, cost structures, and geographic reach. Owners are encouraged to request quotes and ask specific questions about insurance, contract lengths, and local staffing to see which option matches their investment strategy.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is Evolve’s primary value proposition?
Evolve specializes in marketing, listing creation, and booking management at a low 10% fee. Owners handle property upkeep, cleaning, and guest check-ins independently or through recommended vendors.
2. How is AvantStay different from Evolve?
AvantStay is a full-service manager, handling everything from design and cleaning to guest communications and repairs. Unlike Evolve, it often charges a higher percentage but caters to property owners who want a hands-off approach and have a home suited to group travel.
3. Does AvantStay have a minimum property size requirement?
AvantStay typically seeks properties with at least four bedrooms and a layout favorable for group stays, reflecting its emphasis on family gatherings, corporate retreats, and event-friendly spaces.
4. Is Evolve’s service area larger than AvantStay’s?
Yes, Evolve covers most of North America, including the U.S., Canada, and Mexico, through partnerships with local providers. AvantStay focuses on 13 states in the U.S. and Baja California Sur in Mexico, relying on in-house teams for service.
5. Which model is more affordable for hosts?
Evolve usually costs less at 10% of monthly revenue, but owners must manage their own daily operations. AvantStay charges more, yet provides a comprehensive service that can save owners time and hassle.
Takeaway
Deciding between Evolve and AvantStay often comes down to the level of effort you, as a host, are willing or able to commit. Evolve keeps fees to a minimum and excels in digital marketing, dynamic pricing, and booking coordination. However, the owner must either self-manage or hire local services. AvantStay offers a premium, full-service approach, specializing in group-friendly homes that can command higher nightly rates but also entail more complex operations.
For hosts who desire a middle ground—strong marketing combined with optional on-the-ground services—RedAwning can be a compelling alternative. It distributes your property across major channels, handles 24/7 guest inquiries, and allows owners to purchase add-on services in certain markets for a more hands-off arrangement.
RedAwning can help boost occupancy and revenue while still affording you the flexibility to retain some control over daily property operations. In the end, weighing your priorities between cost savings and hands-on service is key to choosing the best manager for your short-term rental.
%201.webp)
%203.webp)
%201.webp)
.webp)
