Airbnb Property Management vs. Self-Management: Which Hosting Style Is Right for You?

Airbnb hosting has taken off in recent years, giving everyday homeowners a chance to earn extra income—or even build a full-time business—by renting out their space. But once you list your property, a big question comes up: should you manage it yourself or hire a property management company to do the heavy lifting?

This decision isn’t just about convenience—it affects how much money you make, how much time you spend running your rental, and the kind of experience your guests will have. Whether you’re aiming for hands-off passive income or a more hands-on approach, choosing the right path can make or break your success as a host.

If you’re leaning toward a done-for-you solution, RedAwning’s property management services make it easy to maximize earnings while minimizing effort.

‍

Understanding Airbnb Property Management

If you're thinking about listing your property on Airbnb but don’t want the hassle of managing everything yourself, hiring a professional Airbnb property management company might be the right move. But what exactly does that mean?

Airbnb property management refers to companies or individuals who handle the day-to-day operations of short-term rental properties on behalf of the owner. Their job is to take the stress off your plate—handling everything from guest communication to pricing strategies—so you can enjoy the benefits of Airbnb income without being on call 24/7.

These managers can be especially helpful for owners who live far from their rental property, host multiple listings, or simply don’t have the time or desire to manage guests and turnovers themselves.

Here’s what most property management companies typically handle:

• Guest communication and support – They respond to inquiries, send check-in instructions, and are available if guests have questions or issues during their stay. It’s like having a customer service rep dedicated to your rental.
• Check-in and check-out coordination – Whether it’s handling key exchanges or setting up smart locks, managers ensure guests get in and out smoothly.
• Cleaning and maintenance – After every checkout, they schedule professional cleaning and ensure the property stays in tip-top shape. They’ll also coordinate repairs if something breaks.
• Dynamic pricing strategies – Most companies use pricing software or internal tools to automatically adjust your nightly rate based on local demand, seasonality, and events—helping you earn more.
• Marketing and listing optimization – They’ll write compelling Airbnb descriptions, take professional photos, and tweak your listing to help it rank higher in search results.
• Regulatory compliance assistance – In cities where short-term rentals face strict rules, a good manager can help you stay compliant with local laws and licensing.

Cost Structure

All this convenience comes at a price. Although RedAwning offers property management services starting at just 10% commission, most Airbnb property managers charge a commission on your booking revenue, typically ranging from 20% to 30%. Some also offer fixed-rate packages or charge additional fees for services like linen rentals or premium cleanings.

While that may seem like a big chunk of your earnings, many hosts find that professional management leads to higher occupancy rates and better guest reviews—which can more than make up for the cost.

In the end, it’s about what you value more: hands-off hosting or maximizing your profits by doing it all yourself. And that’s exactly what we’ll dive into next.

‍

Pros and Cons of Hiring a Property Manager

Let’s face it—managing an Airbnb isn’t always a walk in the park. That’s where property managers come in. They’re like your behind-the-scenes crew, keeping things running smoothly while you focus on other things. But is it worth the cost? Let’s break it down.

Pros

• Time Savings: One of the biggest perks? You get your time back. Property managers handle the daily grind—guest messaging, check-ins, cleaning schedules, pricing adjustments—so you’re not glued to your phone 24/7. Great if you’ve got a full-time job, live far from the property, or just don’t want Airbnb hosting to become your second career.
• Professional Expertise: Experienced managers bring real value to the table. They know how to optimize your listing, adjust pricing to match demand, and create a five-star guest experience. That kind of know-how can lead to better reviews and more consistent bookings.
• Stress Reduction: No more late-night calls about a broken AC or a missing key. Your manager handles the headaches, while you get to enjoy the income without the drama.

Cons

• Cost: Here’s the catch—most property managers charge a percentage of your rental income, usually between 20–30%. That can take a noticeable bite out of your profits, especially in slower seasons.
• Less Control: When someone else is managing your property, you’ll have to let go of the reins a bit. Some hosts don’t mind, but others prefer to be hands-on with things like guest communication or how their home is presented.
• Variable Quality: Not all management companies are created equal. Some are amazing, others… not so much. If you go this route, do your homework, read reviews, and ask for referrals. A great manager can be a game-changer—but the wrong one can do more harm than good.

‍

Understanding Self-Management

Self-managing an Airbnb means you, the host, are the one running the show. You're not handing things off to a property manager—you’re fully in charge of how your short-term rental operates, from the booking to the check-out and everything in between.

That might sound like a lot (and sometimes it is), but for many hosts, the hands-on approach is worth it. You stay connected to your property, control the guest experience, and keep more of the profits.

What Self-Managing Involves

Here’s a breakdown of the key responsibilities you’ll be taking on:

• Creating and optimizing your listing: You’ll write the title and description, choose the best photos, and craft a listing that stands out in search results. It’s also on you to update the calendar, set house rules, and keep everything aligned with Airbnb’s standards.
• Communicating with guests: You’ll be the point of contact for every inquiry, booking request, and midnight “Where’s the Wi-Fi password?” message. Great communication can lead to great reviews, so this part really matters.
• Coordinating cleaning and maintenance: Cleanliness is key for good ratings. You’ll either clean the property yourself or work with a cleaning team you trust. You’ll also need to schedule regular maintenance and respond quickly to anything that breaks—whether it’s a leaky faucet or a busted coffee maker.
• Setting and adjusting pricing: Pricing isn’t a “set it and forget it” deal. You'll need to monitor demand and competition to keep your rates competitive—ideally without underpricing or overpricing your space.
• Handling emergencies and guest issues: Things happen. A guest might get locked out at 2 a.m., or the A/C might go out during a heat wave. When you self-manage, you’re the one getting the call and figuring out the solution, fast.

Helpful Tools and Resources

Thankfully, you don’t have to do it all without help. There are tons of tools that make self-managing smoother and more efficient:

• Dynamic pricing tools like PriceLabs, Wheelhouse, or Beyond adjust your nightly rates based on seasonality, events, and demand in your area.
• Automated messaging platforms like Hospitable or Host Tools can handle guest communication, sending check-in instructions and thank-you notes automatically.
• Cleaning coordination apps such as Turno (formerly TurnoverBnB) help you schedule cleaners and track their progress.
• Task and team management tools like Asana or Slack can keep everything running like clockwork—especially if you grow your hosting business.

‍

Pros and Cons of Self-Managing Your Airbnb

Managing your own Airbnb can be incredibly rewarding—but it's not for everyone. Whether you're a hands-on host or someone just starting out, here’s a real look at what self-management actually involves.

Pros

• Higher Profit Margins: The most obvious perk? You keep more of your money. Without having to pay a property manager 20%–30% of your rental income, you get to pocket the profits. For hosts who are comfortable doing the work themselves, this can add up quickly—especially in high-demand areas.
• Full Control: When you self-manage, every decision is yours. From setting the nightly rate to choosing your cleaning team, you get to run things your way. If you like being in the driver’s seat, this can be empowering. Plus, you can adapt quickly without having to check in with a middleman.
• Personalized Guest Experience: Direct communication with guests gives you the chance to add a personal touch. Whether it's a custom welcome message, a favorite local recommendation, or simply quick responses, guests appreciate it—and they’ll often reflect that in their reviews. Those five-star ratings? They're easier to earn when people feel taken care of by a real human, not just a service.

Cons

• Time-Consuming: There’s no sugarcoating it: managing your Airbnb takes time. Between answering messages, coordinating cleanings, handling check-ins, and making sure everything runs smoothly, it can start to feel like a second job. And if you’re managing more than one property? Even more so.
• You're On the Hook for Everything: When a pipe bursts or a guest locks themselves out at 2 a.m., guess who’s getting the call? That’s right—you. Emergencies and last-minute hiccups are part of the game, and as the manager, it’s your job to handle them.
• Steep Learning Curve: Running a successful Airbnb isn’t just about handing over the keys. You’ll need to learn the ropes of hospitality, pricing strategies, guest communication, and even local rental laws. It’s doable, but there’s definitely a learning curve—especially at the beginning.

‍

Hybrid Approach: Combining Self-Management and Professional Services

Some hosts find that the best of both worlds comes from a hybrid approach. Instead of choosing between full control or full outsourcing, you can mix and match. For example, you might handle guest messaging and pricing strategy yourself, but hire a cleaning crew and a handyman for turnovers and maintenance. Or maybe you use an automated tool for guest check-ins but manage the guest experience personally. It’s all about customizing your setup to fit your lifestyle and strengths.

This kind of flexibility is a big win. It lets you stay involved in the parts of hosting you enjoy (or do well), while handing off the time-consuming or specialized tasks. You’re not locked into a rigid structure—if your schedule changes or your business grows, you can adjust who does what along the way.

Plus, it’s often more affordable than hiring a full-service property manager. You save money by only outsourcing what’s necessary, and because you're still directly involved, you can scale up more easily when adding more listings or branching into new markets.

‍

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Self-Management and Property Management

Not sure which path to take? Here are a few things to think about before you decide how to manage your Airbnb:

• Time Availability: Got the time to answer messages at midnight or deal with a last-minute cleaning issue? If not, handing things off to a manager might make sense.
• Experience and Skills: Are you comfortable with pricing strategies, guest communication, and hospitality know-how? If you're new to this, a pro can help you avoid costly mistakes.
• Financial Goals: Want to keep as much profit as possible, even if it means more work? Go the DIY route. Prefer convenience over squeezing every dollar? Management fees might be worth it.
• Property Location: Living far from your rental? A local property manager can handle things you just can't do remotely—like emergencies or quick turnovers.
• Number of Properties: One listing might be manageable solo. But if you're juggling multiple, outsourcing can help you stay sane and maintain quality across the board.

‍

Wrapping Up

Whether you go the self-management route or bring in the pros, each option has its pros and cons. Self-managing gives you full control and saves on fees, but it takes serious time and effort. Hiring a property manager frees up your schedule and adds expertise, though it comes at a cost.

In the end, it really comes down to your goals, availability, and how hands-on you want to be.

Want less stress and more bookings? RedAwning’s full-service property management can help you earn more while doing less—get started today.

‍