Airbnb & VRBO Performance in Utica Indiana.

RedAwning offers vacation rental property management for busy vacation rental owners and Airbnb hosts. Starts at 10% of revenue.
Schedule a call
Call or text 415-941-5206

Utica, Indiana: Airbnb & VRBO Vacation Rental Market Overview

Despite national trends of slightly declining occupancy rates, the short-term rental market in Utica, Indiana, is maintaining strong performance, with high guest satisfaction and stable revenue prospects, particularly as the late fall season shows promising occupancy and rate increases.

Market overview

Strong Recovery in Utica's Short-Term Rental Market

Despite the broader trends in the U.S. short-term rental industry, Utica, Indiana, is showing promising signs of recovery and stability. While national data indicates that the summer of 2024 saw slightly lower occupancy rates due to increased supply and softening demand, the late fall season is pacing ahead of last year's figures. For instance, nationwide occupancy is expected to be 1% ahead in October and 2% ahead in November compared to the previous year.

Although specific data for Utica is not available, the general trend suggests that short-term rentals in the area could be benefiting from the overall improvement in late fall travel demand. Average daily rates (ADR) are also showing a modest increase, with national ADRs pacing $8 higher per night in October and November compared to last year. This indicates a potential for increased revenue for short-term rental properties in Utica as the season progresses.

Short Term Regulations

Short-Term Rental Regulations in Utica, Indiana for 2024

While specific regulations for Utica, Indiana, are not detailed in the provided sources, here are some general regulations that apply to short-term rentals in Indiana, which would likely be relevant to Utica as well:

Permit Requirements

  • Property owners must obtain a short-term rental permit from the local government. The process and fees vary across different jurisdictions but are capped at a maximum fee of $150. Permits expire after one year but can be renewed without additional cost if not previously revoked.

Zoning and Land Use

  • Compliance with local zoning regulations is mandatory. Local governments have the autonomy to define and regulate short-term rentals, including specific rules about the types of properties that can be rented out and the duration of stay allowed.

Health and Safety Standards

  • Short-term rentals must adhere to state health codes and safety guidelines, including having functional fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, and complying with state electrical, plumbing, and egress standards.

Tax Obligations

  • Owners of short-term rentals are liable for gross retail tax and innkeeper’s tax. A Merchant Certificate is necessary for collecting and submitting these taxes.

Insurance and Liability

  • Standard homeowner’s policies typically do not cover short-term rentals. Owners need to increase their insurance coverage to adequately protect against liabilities such as injuries or property damage.

HOA and Condo Association Rules

  • Compliance with covenants set by Homeowners Associations (HOAs) or condo associations is required. Violating these restrictions can result in severe consequences.

Neighborhood Considerations

  • Owners must be mindful of their neighbors and plan for issues such as guest parking, smoking, pets, and loud music to maintain a positive relationship.

Special Use Requests and Inspections

  • Depending on local regulations, owners may need to complete special use requests and undergo home inspections to ensure compliance with local ordinances.

Local Ordinances

  • Owners must review and comply with the specific short-term rental ordinances of their local town code, which may include requirements for applying for zoning variances or other special permits.

By adhering to these regulations, property owners in Utica, Indiana, can ensure they are operating their short-term rentals in compliance with state and local laws. It is always advisable to consult with a legal expert familiar with local regulations for specific guidance.

Neighborhood Performance

Top Neighborhoods for Airbnb Revenue in Utica, Indiana

1. Jeffersonville Waterfront

  • Appeal: These rentals offer stunning views of the Ohio River, modern amenities, and easy access to downtown Jeffersonville and Louisville. Properties like the "Beachfront River Cottage" and "River Refuge: WATERFRONT" are highly rated for their scenic views, fully stocked kitchens, and private beaches or waterfront decks.

2. Prospect and River Road Area

  • Appeal: This area is known for its scenic river views, proximity to Downtown Louisville, and convenient access to local amenities such as restaurants, shopping centers, and marinas. Rentals like the "Cottage in Louisville, KY on Scenic River Rd" and "Waterside Retreat, Ideal Location" are favored for their location and views.

3. Utica Riverfront and Surrounding Areas

  • Appeal: These areas offer a mix of tranquility and accessibility. Rentals such as the "Riverside Retreat" in Prospect, which is close to Utica, provide updated amenities, non-smoking environments, and beautiful back deck views of the Ohio River. The proximity to Garrett's General Store in downtown Utica and other local attractions adds to their appeal.

4. New Albany and Clark County Waterfront

  • Appeal: While not directly in Utica, these nearby waterfront areas in Clark County are popular due to their historic charm, modern comforts, and riverfront locations. Rentals like the "Lovely Hideaway at 'Sunnyside' on Main" in New Albany and other waterfront properties in Clark County attract guests with their blend of history, contemporary amenities, and scenic riverfront strolls.

Why They Are Appealing

  • Scenic Views and Waterfront Access: Many of these rentals offer breathtaking views of the Ohio River and direct access to waterfront areas, making them ideal for guests seeking a tranquil and scenic stay.
  • Proximity to Local Amenities: These neighborhoods are close to restaurants, shopping centers, and other local attractions, ensuring guests have everything they need within a short distance.
  • Modern Amenities: Fully furnished rentals with updated kitchens, high-speed WiFi, and dedicated work spaces cater to both leisure travelers and digital nomads.
  • Positive Guest Reviews: High ratings and positive reviews from previous guests enhance the credibility and appeal of these rentals.
Meet with a revenue advisor
Design Tips

Creating an Inviting Airbnb in Utica, Indiana: Design and Furnishing Tips

To design an Airbnb in Utica, Indiana, that is both inviting and reflective of the city's unique style, consider the following tips:

Understand Your Target Audience

  • Identify the type of guests you want to attract, such as families, couples, or travelers. This will help you tailor the design and furnishings to their needs and preferences.

Reflect the Local Style

  • Since Utica is known for its rural and natural surroundings, incorporate elements that reflect this, such as rustic decor, natural materials, and earthy color schemes.

Entryway First Impressions

  • Ensure the entryway is welcoming with thoughtful touches like a clean and well-lit space, soft blankets, and a few personal but not intrusive items that tell a story about the location.

Living Room Comfort

  • Focus on creating a comfortable living room with:
  • Good lighting control using lamps and dimmer switches.
  • Soft, clean blankets and pillows with different fill options.
  • Occasional tables for each guest to place their drinks.
  • A layout that encourages conversation and relaxation, including poufs and swivel chairs.

Bedroom Luxury

  • Enhance the bedroom experience with:
  • High-quality bedding, including extra layers stored in the closet.
  • Multiple pillows per guest with different fill options.
  • Bedside tables and lamps for each guest, ideally with USB ports or wireless charging features.
  • Blackout shades to cater to different sleep preferences.

Texture and Dimension

  • Add depth to the space by combining different textures, such as smooth surfaces with handmade or natural textures. For example, pair a smooth metal tray with a handmade textured vase or use a linen pillow next to a wool pillow.

Clean and Inviting Bedding

  • Use white bedding to give a clean and fresh appearance. Invest in a full and fluffy duvet insert to ensure the bed looks luxurious and inviting.

Personal Touches

  • Add personal touches that tell a story about the host and the location without cluttering the space. Use local ceramics, small figurines, or other quirky items that spark interest.

Functional and Comfortable Spaces

  • Ensure that the space is both functional and comfortable. For example, if targeting digital nomads, include a comfortable and quiet workspace. For families or pet owners, organize the outdoor area accordingly.

Vertical Elements

  • Create interest by adding vertical elements such as painted ceilings, wallpaper, or chandeliers to make the space more visually appealing, especially in photos.

DIY and Budget-Friendly Solutions

  • Consider DIY projects to save money, such as painting the walls and ceilings yourself, using plants and mirrors instead of dressers, and opting for vintage books and decor instead of expensive sculptures.
Insider Tips

Local Attractions and Insider Tips for Utica, Indiana

While Utica, Indiana, is a small town and may not have a plethora of attractions within its immediate boundaries, it is situated in a region rich in natural beauty and cultural experiences. Here are some local attractions and insider tips that Airbnb hosts can share with their guests:

Local Attractions

Nearby Steuben County Attractions

  • Pokagon State Park: Known for its outdoor recreation opportunities, including hiking, biking, and the state’s only refrigerated toboggan run, open from the day after Thanksgiving through the last weekend in February.
  • Satek Winery: Northeast Indiana’s first winery, offering free wine tastings seven days a week.
  • Buck Lake Ranch: A popular spot for country, rock, and bluegrass concerts, with cabin rentals, RV sites, and pet-friendly camping.
  • Ridenour Acres: Features an 11-acre corn maze, hayrides, a barrel train, playgrounds, and corn cannons, open weekends from mid-September through October.

Southern Indiana Experiences

  • Ohio River Riverside: Enjoy scenic views, cultural experiences, and family fun along the Ohio River in nearby Clark and Floyd Counties. This area offers a mix of culture, heritage, shopping, and family activities.

Insider Tips

Outdoor Activities

  • Disc Golf Course: Located in Commons Park, Angola, this hilly par 68 course features 18 holes ranging from 210 feet to 578 feet. Guests can bring their own discs or borrow some from the Angola Parks and Recreation Department.
  • Fremont Splash Pad: A free, family-friendly splash pad at Fremont Town Park, open daily from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. from Memorial Day through Labor Day.

Cultural and Entertainment

  • Brokaw Movie House: A vintage 1931 first-run movie theater in downtown Angola that has recently undergone major renovations. It offers a unique cinematic experience.
  • The Backyard Creamery & Mini Golf: Play 18 or 36 holes of miniature golf and enjoy ice cream treats. There are also indoor board games and outdoor lawn games available.

Shopping and Dining

  • Steuben County Farmers Market: Located at 317 S. Wayne St., Angola, this market offers fresh, local food and other local products.
  • Local Wineries and Restaurants: Encourage guests to explore the local wineries and restaurants in the area, such as Satek Winery and the various dining options in downtown Angola.

By sharing these attractions and tips, Airbnb hosts can help their guests make the most of their visit to Utica, Indiana, and the surrounding region.

Practical Tips

Practical Tips to Run a Successful Short-Term Rental Business in Utica, New York

To ensure the success and smooth operation of a short-term rental business in Utica, New York, several practical tips can be implemented:

Noise Regulations and Guest Communication

Inform guests about quiet hours and noise regulations to maintain a peaceful environment for both the guests and the neighbors. Include this information in the house manual and in the listing description to set clear expectations.

Creating a Comprehensive House Manual

Develop both digital and physical house manuals that include essential instructions, such as Wi-Fi passwords, appliance usage, and emergency contact information. This manual should also outline house rules, including quiet hours, to ensure guests are well-informed and respectful of the property.

Simplified Check-in Process

Utilize smart locks to streamline the check-in process, eliminating the need for physical key exchanges. Provide guests with detailed instructions on how to use the smart locks, along with parking instructions accompanied by photos to help them navigate the property easily.

By implementing these measures, you can enhance the guest experience, reduce potential issues, and ensure a smooth and enjoyable stay for your guests in Utica, New York.

Local Vendors

Here are some house cleaning providers that serve or are near Utica, Indiana:

House Cleaning Services

Homeaglow

  • Offers professional, affordable, and background-checked house cleaners.
  • Bookings available for various durations, starting from $19 for 3 hours.
  • Features a ForeverClean membership for discounted rates on future cleanings.

Merry Maids of Central Indiana

  • Although primarily based in Central Indiana, they serve a broader area including regions near Utica.
  • Provides expert cleaning services with a team having 10 to 25 years of experience.
  • Offers a free estimate for their services.

If you are looking for repair or maintenance services specifically, the provided sources do not list any providers in Utica, Indiana, but you may need to check local listings or other resources for such services.

Management fees

Short-Term Rental Management Fees in Utica, Indiana: A Guide to Costs and Services

In Utica, Indiana, managing a short-term rental property can incur management fees that typically range from 10% to 30% of the rental revenue, depending on the level of service provided. Full-service management, which includes comprehensive tasks such as guest communication, marketing, and maintenance, tends to be on the higher end of this spectrum, often ranging between 25% to 30% of the rental income. In contrast, basic services may be more budget-friendly, falling on the lower end of the scale. Additionally, property owners may need to account for extra fees for services like cleaning, repairs, or design enhancements, which can vary based on the specific needs of the property and the services offered by the management company.

Meet with an advisor

Why choose RedAwning

RedAwning is a tech leader in full-service short-term rental management, powered by our exclusive, unmatched tools.
Other property managers
Cost
Starting at 10%
25-40%
Guest communications
5-15 mins / 24 hours a day
1 hour+
Host communications
Dedicated phone and text line with no time on hold
Chat bots, hold lines and email threads
Insurance
Robust liability and dwelling coverage for every reservation
Spotty coverage with low claim approval rates
Contract
No cancellation fees
No contract lock-in
Just 90 days notice to cancel
Cancellation penalties
Number of Channels Your Listing is On
50+
2-4

Experience in numbers

Rest well knowing your property is managed by an experienced team powered by world-class technology.
+10-30%
in gross revenue
4.8 stars
guest rating
14+ years
managing STRs

Short Term Rental Calculator

Find out how much your property in Utica should generate as a short term rental and look at the performance of properties around yours.

35,000+ Properties
Hosts stay with RedAwning
1,000,000,00 Nights Booked
RedAwing knows how to get bookings
50+ Top Booking Channels
More than any other platform available

Furnishing checklist

This comprehensive checklist ensures that your rental is guest-ready with all the essentials to create a comfortable and memorable experience in Utica.

Living Room
Seating: Sofa, armchairs, and ottomans
Coffee Table
Entertainment: Smart TV (with streaming apps) and remote control
Decor: Area rug, wall art, plants, and throw pillows
Lighting: Floor lamp or table lamps
Charging Stations: Power strips or outlets with USB ports
Bedrooms
Beds: High-quality mattress with mattress protector
Linens: At least two sets of sheets per bed
Pillows: Hypoallergenic pillows (2-4 per bed)
Blankets: Extra throw blankets or quilts
Nightstands: With lamps or charging docks
Closet or Storage: Hangers, dresser, or luggage rack
Blackout Curtains or Shades
Bathrooms
Towels: Bath towels, hand towels, washcloths (2 sets per guest)
Shower Curtain & Liner
Toiletries: Shampoo, conditioner, body wash, hand soap
Bathroom Essentials: Toilet paper, tissues, trash bin
Hairdryer
Mirror: Full-length or wall mirror
Dining Area
Dining Table: Seating for the maximum number of guests
Place Settings: Placemats or tablecloths
Centerpiece: Vase with flowers or decorative piece
Kitchen
Appliances: Refrigerator, microwave, toaster, coffee maker, kettle
Cookware: Pots, pans, baking trays
Utensils: Forks, knives, spoons, spatulas, tongs
Dinnerware: Plates, bowls, glasses, mugs (2 sets per guest)
Cutting Board & Knives
Basic Spices & Condiments: Salt, pepper, oil
Cleaning Supplies: Sponge, dish soap, paper towels, trash bags
Outdoor Space (if applicable)
Seating: Outdoor chairs, benches, or lounges
Table: For outdoor dining or drinks
Lighting: String lights or outdoor lanterns
Grill: With necessary utensils and instructions
Outdoor Trash Bin
Extras to Elevate Guest Experience
Welcome Basket: Snacks, water bottles, or wine
Guidebook: Local recommendations and house rules
Board Games or Books: Entertainment for guests
Umbrella & Flashlight
Iron & Ironing Board
Laundry: Washer, dryer, and detergent (if available)
Unlock your home’s potential
Schedule a call to learn more about Awning’s Short Term Rental Property Management Service.
Schedule a call

⇤ Airbnb Statistics for Indiana